Cake Versus Pie

[Homicidal Monkey]

Icecream cake
Chocolate Cake
Shortcake
Pancake
Birthday cake
Batman cake

srsly, cake > pie.

You dont walk into a bakery and order a batman pie, you order a batman cake.
You dont walk into IHOP and order a pie for breakfast, you order a pancake.
You dont walk into a party and get birthday pie, you get birthday cake.

[In7el3ct]

While looking at the cake and pie wiki articles, I came upon something… interesting. Neapolitan Cake Pie.

My vote is for cake, the all out champion of dessert.

[Admiral Refuge]

It's a close one, considering my blackberry pie owns (hard!), but I have to give this one to cake.

[Adulese Games]

Ah, but here is a solid pro-pie argument. Isn't all cake a lie seeded by some AI that is slowly manipulating us through the use of amazing portals?

- Adulese

[shadoweight]

Cake is gonna win this it is as easy as pie or easy being better then pie

[Robin]

@Rodriguez:

> Ah, but here is a solid pro-pie argument. Isn't all cake a lie seeded by some AI that is slowly manipulating us through the use of amazing portals?
>
> - Adulese

No. No it is not.

[MMORPG DUDE]

Cake pwns pie.

Pie has to be named after cake to make it look better hence "Cheese Cake"

[Homicidal Monkey]

@Rodriguez:

> Ah, but here is a solid pro-pie argument.
>
> Isn't all cake a lie;
> seeded by some AI;
> that is slowly manipulating us;
> through the use of amazing portals?

But with each pro-pie argument is a pro-cake response.

The reason why;
it is cake instead of pie;
Is because who would under go pathos;
for the sake of pie through using portals?

[Robin]

@MMORPG:

> Cake pwns pie.
>
> Pie has to be named after cake to make it look better hence "Cheese Cake"

… Cheese Cake isn't a pie.

[Ruins of Hell]

[Surprisingly, it is.](http://www.answerbag.com/q_view/43299)

[jna]

I should be on pie's side. After all, my name was changed to pieman Jna for like a month or two.

[Homicidal Monkey]

cakes were invented over 4000 years ago. Pies were invented about half a millennium ago. Ergo, pies are newfags.

[Robin]

@Soul:

> [Surprisingly, it is.](http://www.answerbag.com/q_view/43299)

They have a base of crushed biscuit which is then covered in a cream cheese, sugar and cream mix and is then covered in fruit compote.

If America crusts off their cheesecakes, then good for them, but that doesn't mean you can categorise all cheesecakes as pies.

[lollicat]

The cake is a lie.
That's why pie is better. ;D

[balliztik1]

Cheesecake is a filling. It's neither explicitly a pie nor a cake. If you bake it in a cake tin, it's a cake. If you put it in a pie crust, it's pie. It really depends on how you serve it. I've never had it baked, myself, but I've also never had it in a crust.

[lollicat]

I'm pretty sure cheesecake is most often referring to the middle part, which is more of a creamy pie filling than a cake.

[balliztik1]

@Lollicat:

> I'm pretty sure cheesecake is most often referring to the middle part, which is more of a creamy pie filling than a cake.

This is true, but it does not make it a pie, still. Chocolate pudding is used in a chocolate pie, but chocolate pudding is not by itself a pie.

The cheesecake filling is not a pie, nor a cake, but more an ingredient that can be used in either.

[MrHappySmore]

I do enjoy a good 'ol American Apple Pie!

[lollicat]

Well, sure, but I've never seen cheesecake filling in…cake. xD

[Chakkra]

Piece de resistance

[Dirt Cake](http://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/8/83/Gummy_worm_dirt_cake.jpg/220px-Gummy_worm_dirt_cake.jpg&imgrefurl=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirt_cake&usg=__3btDT4qObqxdGBlwO9NV6M6JoZk=&h=165&w=220&sz=13&hl=en&start=1&sig2=5l1y6yxEXFENWYTegm4tQw&um=1&itbs=1&tbnid=PZShVLcqbjNE2M:&tbnh=80&tbnw=107&prev=/images%3Fq%3Ddirt%2Bcake%2Bwiki%26um%3D1%26hl%3Den%26sa%3DN%26tbs%3Disch:1&ei=kWznS-DBAYKglAfe_KiGBA)

[Sojourner]

@Mike:

> I say Pie wins. I love certain cakes, but I love the varieties of pies. You can't find blackberry, cherry, apple, or peach cakes.

Yes you can! In fact, the best recipie for apple pie (Soft crust) Is actually apple cake pudding!

[mrmiguu]

"Give me cake, or give me death!" - Cakitarian

[demon xxx x]

I love me some cherry pie. ;]

[Techno 5.0]

I get a message on my phone that woke me up saying that this topic discusses a very serious topic…

Wth lol xD

pie is pretty damn good
I like cake too but I am a VERY picky cake person
chocolate fudge cake with a glass of milk is my way to go

BUT. I do like sweet potato pie, pumpkin pie, apple pie :)

[demon xxx x]

Bro, what about that cherry pie?