[C&C]Emberseal Tileset

[Jeff]

I post here the could be emberseal tileset.

>! The old tiles: Please say which style you like best, and Criticize and such :D  
>! 
>! 
>! UPDATE: I've completely reworked grass and dirt tiles, as well as added long grass.  Hope you like it!
>! please C&C the crap out of it.
–-Update Nov 18---
>! I've done trees as well as add more contrast to the original grass tiles.  Please Criticize!
>! 
>! –-UPDATE NOVEMBER 25--
I've done the sand tiles and water, but something looks wrong about it.  Can't place my finger on what though.  Please C&C.
NOTE: please ignore the blue water pallette to the left of the tree roots.  I cleaned those up, just too lazy to reupload it for such a tiny thing xD
>! **UPDATE DEC. 1**
>! I have redone the trees completely, as well as reworked the water a bit.
>! p.s. I actually took the effort to crop the image just to the map this time :P

UPDATE DEC. 4
I fixed some pallettes and edited the trees a bit, making them more cylindrical looking and taking out dithering.  Please give opinions!

[Bafoon]

I say second. Both could use a little work though..i dont know what though but it looks a bit funny.

[Jeff]

Woops, i forgot to upload the third.  I personally like the third the most myself.

[Bafoon]

I still say second, looks more realistic. The first and second do t even look like they have leaves, just bushes of..green.

[Jeff]

okay, I'm thinking about making a copy paste tree with distinguished leaves, but idk

[Bafoon]

thats what I uasally do. Try it and ill c and c that as well.

[Kusy]

Third. Anyhow - from my own experience - don't do dem opinion threads, do your best, go with what you like, eventualy fix things when you are done with everything and people notice that something's wrong.

Also, I would be more concerned with the grass than the trees. They don't fit eachother and since the trees look better (in the third image imo) you should adjust your grass to match them.

[Bafoon]

i like the trunk of 3 and leaves of 2\.

[Jeff]

Kusy:  You mean the pallette of the grass, the shape of it, or the transitions?  I'm not done with the transitions, I want to work with it more. I've also been thinking about doing shrub type grass with little weeds in it thats more like the sword of Mana grass.  I did this grass when I was just begginning; everything else is like a month newer.

[luriok]

Well you might wanna tone down the grass, but I like the second or third trees (Can't decide), but the first ones look pretty bad.

[Guest]

i like the second…trees remind me of scribblenauts....i vote 2nd  :azn:

[Jeff]

First trees were kind of scribbled, i was going for a certain style but i couldn't pull it off.  I will also change the grass' pallette, its kind of bright and stands out a little much.  Anyone have opinions on the dirt?

[VitinhooxD]

They are really random line art but they are….ok

[Kusy]

@Jeff:

> the pallette of the grass, the shape of it, or the transitions

yes.

[Bafoon]

He means just everything in general I guess.

[Guest]

"Snow Map" doesn't look so snowy ;D

[Bafoon]

Its a mind trick.

[Kusy]

@Rilêy¿!¡:

> He means just everything in general I guess.

yes.

[Guest]

Wouldn't that be spamming Kusy ;D? (Yes, I know the answer is yes.)

[Bafoon]

@Sekaru:

> Wouldn't that be spamming Kusy ;D? (Yes, I know the answer is yes.)

Wouldn't that be spamming Sekaru? ;D? (Yes, I know the answer is yes.)

[Patrick]

The grass is the same for all?

Anyway, I like the first and last trees.

[Bafoon]

Why would he change the grass? It's the tree's hes looking for some C&C on.

[Patrick]

But the grass and dirt sucks.

[Bafoon]

I think they look fine. Lets get back on topic now about the tree's.

[VitinhooxD]

@мсичġġєт:

> But the grass and dirt sucks.

+1