Little Sigpic

[Urumil]


Comments, please…

[Techno 5.0]

i cant really read the text very well

and if you were goin for a glossy look you failed at that
overall
a 3.5/10

[Marsh]

Looks alright, it is a tad hard to read. Also the grass then changing to brick is kind out of place.

[Niko]

For the circle on the top, you need to take the opacity down way more. Add a border and it wont be too bad.

[Techno 5.0]

and change text

[Devogen]

3 things.

1\. Font is awful with that white glow behind it.
It also appears to be on-top of your glass effect… not very effective.
You are trying to make the appearance of a glass or reflective item, byt throwing things on top of it, all you do is make it look like you have pasted a white ellipse to the top of the image and made it transparent.

2\. The glass effect over the top fails for 3 reasons.
    * It looks better inverted
    * needs more opacity like niko said, and a border also.
    * I can see the join in the middle of the reflection layer - its off by    about 3mm vertically. (just uinder the Y) You could have done that in one piece very easily and not 2 halves.

3\. use some sort of blend on your pictures. In P.S terms, use a linear opacity that blends from left to right and vice versa for the other side - they will merge together without that ugly contrast.

2/10

[Urumil]

@Devogen:

> 3 things.
>
> 1\. Font is awful with that white glow behind it.
> It also appears to be on-top of your glass effect… not very effective.
> You are trying to make the appearance of a glass or reflective item, byt throwing things on top of it, all you do is make it look like you have pasted a white ellipse to the top of the image and made it transparent.
>
> 2\. The glass effect over the top fails for 3 reasons.
>     * It looks better inverted
>     * needs more opacity like niko said, and a border also.
>     * I can see the join in the middle of the reflection layer - its off by    about 3mm vertically. (just uinder the Y) You could have done that in one piece very easily and not 2 halves.
>
> 3\. use some sort of blend on your pictures. In P.S terms, use a linear opacity that blends from left to right and vice versa for the other side - they will merge together without that ugly contrast.
>
> 2/10

Thanks for that quite detailed review, Devogen.

@Ninja-Tech:

> and change text

No, lol.