Which to choose, which to choose…

[IceCream Tuesday]

Selout

http://pixel-zone.rpgdx.net/shtml/tut-selout.shtml

[Guest]

I think honestly you should do option 3 but with a thinner outline. I like the thick outline but I dont like how overpowering the black is.

[boyesjs03]

I agree with CM :-)

[Guest]

I just checked, and the dark brown outline is only 1 px. I don't know what you did with the thin outline but if you can emulate that with the brown outline, that'd one sexy sprite.

[Zappy]

… I feel like your advice could be pretty valuable, but I have no idea what you mean, aha. Care to expand/rephrase ?

Also, how are these tiles looking so far ?


Does the grass work?

[Guest]

I like the grass but it needs more "blades" to it. Bladed grass. As far as the sprite goes, I like the thick black outline, but I think black is too overpowering. It would look good with a thick brown outline instead of the black.

[Guest]

style 2 looks awfull in map i go for 1:D

[DMF]

no thick outline looks nice to me. 

[Xolani]

I like the thinner outline of style one. The other ones seem to draw your eye to them too much instead of the actual character.