Help Me Decide?

[Irhymer]

~~Hey, its me again. So this time I was going for a very small 16x16 sprite, and it evolved into a more pixelated 32x32\. My problem is, I want to start spriting more with it, but I have 4 different versions I saved as I made changes. Let me know which you think looks best, & you would love to see in a game (includes base, and zombie)~~  ;)

>! >! **[1st Attempt]**
>! >! **[2nd Attempt]**
**[3rd Attempt]**
>! **[Final Attempt]**

[Removed]

_Thanks for the comments, I've decided on the base and graphics  ;)_

-Jake

[Sealbreaker]

3rd attempt with a bit more blood on the zombie.

-seal

[Ezand]

@Sealbreaker:

> 3rd attempt with a bit more blood on the zombie.
>
> -seal

I agree and it looks very simple and good :)

[Irhymer]

Alright, thanks! I was stuck between 3 and 4\. Will add more blood to the zombie and work on some sprites right now  :)

-Jake

[ceriux]

yeah both 3 and 4 are the best.

[Guest]

4\. I Think 3 would look awkward when you were doing animations.

working on another zombie-ish game? or the one that's in the show-off section?

[Irhymer]

@AmSamurai:

> 4\. I Think 3 would look awkward when you were doing animations.
>
> working on another zombie-ish game? or the one that's in the show-off section?

Hm.. its a tough choice, I like the rounded edges on 4, but I somewhat still like 3\. Will try animating both though.  ;)

& No, not a zombie game. But if I do make a game it would include the zombies. At the moment, I'm just freelance spriting.
–---------------------------

**Heres a Mockup I made with the [3rd] sprites:**

-Jake

[Guest]

@[Jake:

> link=topic=69415.msg746711#msg746711 date=1298742344]
> Hm.. its a tough choice, I like the rounded edges on 4, but I somewhat still like 3\. Will try animating both though.  ;)
>
> & No, not a zombie game. But if I do make a game it would include the zombies. At the moment, I'm just freelance spriting.
> –---------------------------
>
> **Heres a Mockup I made with the [3rd] sprites:**
> 
>
> -Jake

as far as outlining, yeah, 3 is nicer. I just dunno what it would look like pieced together. I might change my mind after seeing the animations.

I like 4 because the line art is similar to pokemon sprites. That is basically my favorite outlining for sprites.

[Irhymer]

Ok, heres one more comparison between the two before I try animating #4 (I tried animating #3 and it was horrible lol..)

                      **[#3 vs #4]**
 

–---------------------------
@AmSamurai:

> I like 4 because the line art is similar to pokemon sprites. That is basically my favorite outlining for sprites.

Yea, I agree. Im leaning more towards that one now. Especially because I'm having trouble animating #3..

-Jake

[NightmareX91]

I like 4\. I dislike the feet on 3 :3

[Irhymer]

Removed

Thanks for the comments, I've decided on the base and graphics!

-Jake